Comparing Ceramic Tile vs Laminate Flooring for Your Basement: Pros, Cons, and Costs

2019 Homestars Winner badge for Best Of Awards in Toronto
2020 Homestars Winner badge for Best Of Awards in Toronto
2021 Homestars Winner badge for Best Of Awards in Toronto
2021 Diamond Winner badge for Capable Group, Toronto's choice for basement renovation and basement finishing services.
2022 Diamond Winner badge for Capable Group, Toronto's choice for basement renovation and basement finishing services.
Table of Contents

Understanding Ceramic Tile

What is Ceramic Tile?

Ceramic tile is a great flooring option for a basement floor, despite being hard, cold, and unforgiving underfoot. Made from natural clay and fired at high temperatures, ceramic tiles offer various flooring options in colors, textures, and sizes. This adaptability allows homeowners to select styles that enhance their personal aesthetics, whether they prefer a classic, rustic look or a sleek, modern finish.

Additionally, ceramic tiles provide endless possibilities to transform your basement environment. They impart a luxurious look and feel, adding elegance and sophistication to any basement setting. However, they can be cold underfoot, making cozy slippers a necessity during colder months in seasonal climates.

Installation and Cost Insights

When installing ceramic tile in your basement, it is important that the job is done properly and efficiently. The installation process includes thorough floor preparation, tile layout and meticulous adhesion to ensure long-lasting beauty. The high upfront investment can be daunting, typically ranging from $32 to $129 per square meter.

However, the short-term costs are outweighed by long-term benefits, which are many and varied. When you consider their durability and ease of maintenance, ceramic tiles are one of the most cost-effective choices available over the lifetime of the product. Ceramic tiles provide a long-lasting, hard surface that holds up to all day foot traffic and humidity that comes with a basement location.

On the other hand, carpet tiles are simpler to replace if they get damaged. This is what makes them the perfect option for buyers who want to invest in high-quality materials that are sure to stand the test of time.

Pros of Ceramic Tile

Here are just a few ways that ceramic tiles can improve basement environments. They are also incredibly durable, standing the test of wear and tear far better than most other flooring choices. Their durability and resistance to water and stains make them especially well-suited for basements, which are often vulnerable to moisture.

In addition, this water-resistant quality helps ceramic tiles hold onto their new, clean look for a longer time, so you can enjoy a consistently polished appearance. In doing so, they provide an unmatched diversity of design possibilities, enabling homeowners to create the look and feel they want.

Ceramic tiles provide peace of mind and stability since they will not warp in damp conditions unlike alternatives such as engineered hardwood.

Cons of Ceramic Tile

Even with all of the positives ceramic tiles bring, they still have some negatives. Yet they can also come across as harsh and forbidding. This isn’t great news for anyone who wants a soft, warm floor underfoot. Alternatives such as cork flooring offer a cushioned feel underfoot as well as added sound insulation.

Ceramic tiles also demand a greater upfront investment than alternatives such as laminate or carpet tiles. Their installation can be very difficult due to the expertise required. Their repair can be complicated and labor-intensive—not so easy as swapping out a carpet tile when the need arises.

Homeowners will need to consider these issues against their expectations for a premium, durable flooring option.

Advantages of Ceramic Tile

With superior durability, moisture-resistance, and aesthetic versatility, ceramic tiles are a great flooring option for basement areas. In addition to their aesthetic appeal, ceramic tiles provide great advantages to homeowners, making them a perfect fit for anyone wanting to improve their basement spaces with top-grade flooring materials.

1. Durability Benefits

Face-Impex ceramic tiles are world famous for their hardness and are considered a great flooring option for various basement areas. Durable as they are beautiful, ceramic tiles, made from natural clay and typically coated with a glaze, can last through decades of wear and tear. Their sturdy quality also makes them a smart long-term investment for any household, especially in humid basements where moisture can be a concern.

Perhaps most importantly, ceramic tiles are unique in that they never wear out, making them an ideal flooring choice for finished basements. They stand the test of time, beauty, and functionality, even under the most demanding daily use. With many ceramic tile installations lasting over 50 years, homeowners will feel at ease knowing their installation will endure.

Although ceramic tiles demand a high upfront cost, their durability and timelessness offset the price, making them a wise, economical investment long term in any flooring project.

2. Moisture Resistance Features

Perhaps the most outstanding feature of ceramic tiles is how well they resist moisture. This allows them to be a great choice for basements, which are sometimes susceptible to moisture. The glaze on the tiles gives them a non-porous surface that stops water from penetrating, absorbing, and causing damage.

Ceramic tile is a great option for wetter areas. This benefit contributes to them being less likely to hold mold or mildew, helping create a healthier home. Homeowners in Toronto and the surrounding areas typically have basements, which can act as additional living spaces.

The moisture-resistant characteristics of ceramic tiles are also a priceless benefit in these homes.

3. Easy Maintenance

Another benefit of ceramic tile is they’re known for low maintenance. Their non-porous surface is easy to maintain, needing only routine sweeping and some occasional mopping to keep them looking their best. Their effortless maintenance elevates them further as the premier surface for healthy homes.

This unique feature makes it one of the best at killing allergens and dust. Ceramic tiles can go without special treatments and sealants to preserve their beauty, making them a lower maintenance alternative to other flooring solutions.

This ease of maintenance is what makes ceramic tiles an ideal option for fast-paced homes.

4. Versatile Aesthetic Options

Ceramic tiles offer an incredible variety of looks. Homeowners can quickly transform the look of their basements to reflect their personal style and preferences. Ceramic tiles are available in virtually every dimension and color imaginable.

They can even professionally reproduce the appearance of natural stone, wood, or other fabrics. This versatility guarantees that no matter your decor style, there is a ceramic tile design to complement it perfectly.

Face-Impex tiles are extremely popular in homes. More than that, they make any space more beautiful and valuable! Their natural clay composition also contributes to their beauty, grace, and authenticity to the design.

Comparing Laminate Flooring

What is Laminate Flooring?

With its wide range of designs and natural surface aesthetics, laminate flooring remains a top choice for homeowners looking to maximize their creative spaces. The product’s core is high-density fiberboard (HDF). It has the same kind of photographic printed layer that realistically replicates the look of wood, stone, or tile, plus a super durable clear wear layer.

That construction is what allows laminate flooring to have such a realistic look of much more expensive materials, all while being budget friendly. It’s a favorite choice for living rooms and bedrooms. It provides a chic and functional option that works in harmony with any design aesthetic.

Installation and Cost Insights

One of the more unique features of laminate flooring is how simple it is to install. Plus, its easy installation process means it’s a great option for DIYers. In addition, its ingenious click-and-lock mechanism makes setup a breeze.

Considering how small most laminate flooring projects are, you can knock out most jobs in a single day! In general, laminate flooring is more cost-effective than ceramic tile. You can expect to pay laminate anywhere between $3 and $9 per square foot.

Its affordability is just one reason that makes it such a popular option. Additionally, its aesthetic flexibility gives you the power to elevate your home while staying within your budget.

Pros of Laminate Flooring

Laminate flooring comes with numerous benefits that make it an attractive option for any homeowner. Its remarkable durability ensures outstanding performance for 10 to 25 years. This is assuming you’re using a quality product and you’re not using it in a very intensive way.

This durability also makes it a smart investment for places with heavy foot traffic. Laminate flooring gives you thousands of options when it comes to design and finish. This provides an opportunity for homeowners to achieve their desired aesthetic look without the high price of natural products.

If you’re in a warmer climate, laminate flooring always feels comfortable underfoot year-round. This feature also adds a practical benefit to its extremely long list of advantages.

Cons of Laminate Flooring

Though laminate flooring is a clear winner in many categories, it’s not without its disadvantages. However, it does not fare well with constant moisture. This vulnerability can create problems in humid climates, particularly in environments such as kitchens or bathrooms where water contact is frequent.

In extreme cold conditions, laminate flooring can have issues with humidity. Because of this, it can make a space feel much colder during winter than other flooring options. It also comes with a good lifespan of 10 to 25 years.

However, that’s pretty short compared to tile flooring, which has a lifespan of 50 years or longer. You need to balance these considerations against each other. They are very important in determining whether or not laminate flooring is the best fit for your unique needs and situation.

Key Considerations for Basements

Assess Moisture Levels

Whether you’re replacing your basement flooring or starting fresh, moisture is an important concept to understand. Relative humidity is often higher in basements, at 60-70% on average. This unique environment can have a profound impact on flooring selection.

For example, even though tile can add a lot of beauty to your basement, it is still cold and hard. This can translate into warm toes in the winter, particularly in climates with a marked seasonal change. On the other hand, laminates and hardwoods are a no-go unless you’re lucky enough to have an incredibly dry basement.

Cork comes in as a clear winner thanks to its natural anti-bacterial properties as well as its moisture repellant structure. Plus, it’s rubbery feel underfoot makes it feel soft on the feet and no more slippers required.

Evaluate Durability Needs

The longevity of basement flooring is a top consideration. Basements are usually the most multifunctional spaces of the house, acting as everything from a playroom to a home gym. This also requires the flooring to be durable against high-movement activity.

Tiles provide a strong solution that stand up to years of heavy use while maintaining their contemporary style. They are very unforgiving on a slip. Laminate, though gorgeous, might not stand up to moisture as tile or cork would.

This is why cork provides such a unique combination of durability and comfort. It also absorbs impact and resists wear, making it a great choice for busy families. Consider these pros and cons against your individual priorities to make sure the flooring can stand up to the demands of your lifestyle.

Maintenance Requirements

Avoiding maintenance is a significant reason why certain flooring options that require more care are less popular in basement areas. The ongoing maintenance cost for various flooring options, such as tile or laminate, is negligible. On average, the maintenance costs for basement flooring options range from CAD 0.67 to CAD 3.35 per square meter annually, depending on the flooring material.

Tile, favored for its easy upkeep, could also have reduced maintenance costs. Laminate might need to be replaced more often because it’s more susceptible to moisture damage. Cork, with its natural resilience, should be resealed every so often to keep its water-resistant qualities intact.

Being aware of these flooring costs will prepare you for future upkeep, ensuring your basement floor remains stunning for years to come.

Aesthetic Preferences

Aesthetics are a big factor in selecting flooring. Selecting the perfect flooring can elevate the quality of your basement’s decor. With all the available styles and colors, tile can add a beautiful, high-end feel to your new basement.

Its chill vibe might not be for everyone. Laminate provides the warm look of natural wood without the luxury expense of high-end hardwood. Cork, by contrast, delivers a distinctive appearance that merges the opulence of exotic woods with the welcoming warmth of any wood product.

Be sure to think about how each choice will work with your overall plan for the area. The best possible decision will do more than just match your home’s style—it will improve your quality of life.

Making the Right Choice

Cost Considerations

When choosing basement flooring, budget is often one of the most important considerations. Ceramic tiles present great long-term value with their remarkable durability. Plus, many installations can last 50 years or longer, giving them the long-term return on investment advantage.

Upfront costs can be more expensive, especially with premium products. On the other hand, vinyl plank flooring makes a strong argument for anyone who is looking to save money but not sacrifice value. Vinyl flooring also offers an extremely budget-friendly alternative for homeowners.

If you are considering installation, expect that to add another CAD 2 to CAD 6 per square meter. Be sure to consider long-term maintenance costs, too. They are usually between CAD 1-2 per square meter per year, depending on the type of flooring.

This low maintenance cost also guarantees your flooring will continue to look and perform at its best, avoiding premature wear and damage.

Preparing the Subfloor

Proper preparation of the subfloor is critical to the success of both tile and vinyl installations, particularly when considering various flooring options like laminate and concrete flooring. Prior to the installation of ceramic tiles, it is very important to have a clean, smooth, dry, and level subfloor. This meticulous preparation ensures a uniform appearance and extends the durability of the flooring surface.

It’s essential that the subfloor be completely dry, as any moisture can break down the adhesive that holds the tiles in place. When it comes to vinyl flooring, the preparation is a little less rigorous, but just as crucial. Vinyl’s water resistance makes it a great flooring option for basements, especially in humid basements where the average relative humidity is 60-70%.

Unlike other types of flooring, vinyl flooring is more resistant to moisture and therefore can hold up better against spills. On the other hand, laminate flooring cannot withstand warping. So, taking the time to get the subfloor ready will ensure the best long-term performance and look from your flooring choice.

By focusing on proper subfloor preparation, homeowners can maximize the benefits of their selected flooring materials, ensuring that their flooring project is a success in any basement setting.

Installation Process Overview

The installation process is quite different between ceramic tiles and vinyl flooring. Ceramic tile installation is an art as much as a science. Each tile has to be meticulously laid, spaced, and grouted, making it very labor intensive.

Although the process is labor-intensive, it creates a durable and attractive surface that can offer a lifespan of 100 years or more. Vinyl flooring, by contrast, has an easier installation.

Vinyl planks or tiles can be easily and quickly installed, sometimes with no need for adhesives or grout lines. Vinyl’s ease of installation also makes it appealing.

It’s particularly wonderful in places like basements, where the conditions are frequently far from ideal. Either one provides exceptional durability. The decision is often made based on ease of installation versus the beauty and durability you desire.

Table of Contents
Get Started on Your Dream Basement Renovation

Get A FREE 3D Rendering

Our Phone Number

Tel: (905) 889-0025

Our Showroom:

830 Rowntree Dairy Rd unit 23, Woodbridge, ON L4L 5V3

General Questions

info@capablegroupinc.ca

Get Your Estimate or Call Now: (905) 889-0025

We are very proud of the service we provide and stand by every basement we carry.

Scroll to Top